Recently, at the Glendale Courthouse, Los Angeles County Superior Court, Escovar Law, APC represented a client charged with a violation of Penal Code section 242, Simple Battery. Mr. Steve Escovar was able to persuade the court to grant diversion pursuant to Penal Code Section 1001.95, 1001.96, 1001.97, also known as Judicial Diversion.
In this case, the client was released from local custody from the police station, but after the client’s release, immigration officials (ICE) took the client into custody. Mr. Escovar’s creative advocacy, including proposing dismissal through People v. Chavez and Judicial Diversion accompanied with an apology letter, allowed the client’s case to be dismissed through Judicial Diversion only 2 weeks after the arraignment without the presence of the client in court, since the client remained in immigration custody throughout the life of the case.
Mr. Escovar Represented the Client in Court Without the Client’s Presence Pursuant to Penal Code Section 977(a)
Since the client was charged with a misdemeanor (and the charge was not one of the enumerated un-qualifying charges) Mr. Steve Escovar appeared in court without the presence of the client pursuant to Penal Code section 977.
Creativity For Equitable Solutions
Due to the facts of the case, the client was eligible for the misdemeanor to be dismissed through diversion, but the client was in Immigration custody. Typically, the judges want the client to be present for granting of diversion and for the case to be dismissed.
People v. Chavez Empowers a Judge to Dismiss a Case in the Interest of Justice Per Penal Code Section 1385 at Any Point Between the Arraignment and Until the Completion of Probation
Mr. Steve Escovar advocated for the client to the judge proving that the client had been in Immigration custody for over 60 days. Mr. Escovar further articulated that the client’s time spent in custody was at least an indirect result of the incident.
Mr. Escovar then orally proposed that the judge dismiss the case pursuant to People v. Chavez, which held, that a trial court judge can dismiss a case in the interest of justice per Penal Code section 1385 at any point between arraignment until probation is completed.
According to People v. Chavez (2018) 4 Cal.5th 771 “A trial court has broad power to dismiss an action against a criminal defendant in 'furtherance of justice' under Penal Code section 1385.” (People v. Chavez (2018) 4 Cal.5th 771, 776.) The Chavez court further held, “[a] trial court's power to provide relief under section 1385 depends on when a request for relief is made.” (Id. at p. 789.) “At any time before a criminal defendant pleads guilty, receives a suspension of sentence, begins a term of probation, or, indeed, completes it, the defendant may invite the trial court to act in the interests of justice and dismiss the action against him.” (Ibid.) “By the time the defendant has completed probation, however, the trial court's power under section 1385 to grant him the relief he seeks has run out.” (Ibid.) “The action against the defendant has ceased, the court may no longer impose a final judgment on him, and the court's dismissal power under section 1385 has expired.” (Ibid.)
The Judge considered the proposal but preferred Judicial Diversion (JD), indicating that he felt JD was better suited for the present case.
The Client’s Apology Letter and Judicial Diversion
Mr. Escovar then proposed that the client write an apology letter as the condition of JD. The Judge agreed that a Judicial diversion was appropriate accompanied by an apology letter. The client personally wrote a handwritten, thoughtful apology letter while in immigration custody. The letter was filed with the court, the Judge was impressed by the authentic and genuine contrition by the client and the Judge Ordered the Judicial Diversion terminated and the case dismissed, only two weeks after the arraignment!
Case Dismissed Through Judicial Diversion in Only 2 Weeks Without the Presence of the Client
In general, Judicial Diversion is a yearlong process, with Mr. Escovar’s advocacy and creativity his client with a Misdemeanor, in immigration custody was given judicial diversion and completed the JD in only 2 weeks!
Another great result!